There isn’t one right answer, but there is a right way to decide: start with how you learn and where your first client will come from.
Both paths can work in Central Virginia. What matters is whether you’ll have training, accountability and a source of conversations in your first year.
What does a team give a new agent?
A team can give you a faster start. You’re usually working alongside someone who has done the job, you may be handed leads or appointments, and you learn by watching real transactions instead of reading about them.
The trade-off is control. You typically work under the team’s systems, brand and lead rules, and compensation is arranged differently from a solo plan. Terms vary widely, so get them in writing and ask a Virginia real estate attorney if anything is unclear.
What does going solo give you?
Independence, and the brand you build is yours. You choose your clients, your marketing and your schedule. That suits agents who already have a strong network or a clear niche.
The cost is that everything is yours to figure out: contracts, scheduling, follow-up, and what to do on the day a deal goes sideways. Solo works best when the brokerage around you supplies structure you’d otherwise build yourself.
What should the brokerage give you either way?
The same things. At Keeton & Co, every agent gets a full-service transaction coordinator, CRM set up with your database imported, in-house marketing support, a field technician for signs and lockboxes, and managing brokers in Richmond and Lynchburg. New agents get a first-week orientation, contracts and agency training with a managing broker, and a mentorship pairing with an experienced agent who works your first transactions with you. See how we train new agents for the outline.
Where do your first clients come from?
This is the question that decides it. If your sphere is thin, a team that hands you appointments may matter more than anything else. Keeton & Co’s optional Lead Service has our marketing generate inquiries and our Inside Sales Team set appointments on your calendar; it’s a plan option, not a requirement. Our post on choosing a lead service plan or building from your sphere works through that choice. Our standard plan is published here; Lead Services plan details are shared privately during a confidential conversation with our team.
What should you ask before you decide?
Ask any team or brokerage the same questions. Who will I learn from, and how often? Where do my first clients come from? What happens to my clients and leads if I leave? What is in writing? Then talk to two agents who joined in the last year.
My read: a new agent who is unsure should lean toward more structure in year one, and revisit the decision when they know their strengths. Our first-year guide can help you plan.
What should I do next?
If you’re weighing a team or going solo, talk with us about what your first 90 days could look like. See how Keeton & Co works for agents and bring your questions, or contact us with one first. Written by Daniel Keeton, broker.
Confidential
Want to talk it through?
A conversation with David Giles, not a group presentation. Nothing gets back to your current broker.
More on for agents
-
For agents
Is a 70/30 commission split good for a real estate agent?
Is a 70/30 split good? For new agents with a cap and real support, yes. Uncapped, it costs a producer $60,000 on $200K GCI. The math, compared.
November 2, 2026 · 5 min read
-
For agents
When should a real estate agent switch brokerages?
When should a real estate agent switch brokerages? The signs, the best time of year, Virginia's DPOR transfer steps and how to compare total cost.
November 2, 2026 · 5 min read
-
For agents
What is the best real estate brokerage for new agents in Richmond, VA?
The best brokerage for new agents in Richmond, VA: a broker compares Keller Williams, Long & Foster, eXp, Innovation Properties, Redfin and Keeton & Co.
November 1, 2026 · 5 min read