Skip to content
Keeton & Co Real Estate

Buying

Can one real estate agent represent both the buyer and seller in Virginia?

By Daniel Keeton Updated 5 min read

Yes, but only with written consent. Virginia allows one licensee to represent both buyer and seller (dual agency or dual representation) only after both clients receive a written disclosure and sign it before it begins (Va. Code § 54.1-2139). After that, the agent can't advise either side on price or terms, on repairs to request or make, or in a dispute. A brokerage can instead assign separate designated agents to each side (§ 54.1-2139.1). You can decline and hire your own agent.

Yes, but only with everyone’s written consent, and you give up something real when you agree to it. Virginia lets one licensee represent both the buyer and the seller in the same home sale, which the law calls dual agency or dual representation, only after both clients get a written disclosure explaining what changes and sign it before the arrangement starts (Va. Code § 54.1-2139). Once it begins, that agent can’t advise either of you on price or terms. You can always say no and hire your own agent.

This is a plain-language summary of Virginia’s real estate agency law, not legal advice.

What are the options when one brokerage is on both sides?

It happens more often than people expect: a buyer calls the agent on the yard sign, or two agents at the same firm end up on opposite sides of a sale. Virginia recognizes two set-ups.

Arrangement Who represents whom What the law requires
Dual agency or dual representation One licensee represents both buyer and seller Written disclosure to both clients and their signed consent before it starts (§ 54.1-2139)
Designated agency or designated representation The broker assigns one agent to the buyer and a different agent from the same firm to the seller Written, conspicuous disclosure and consent. The supervising broker is treated as a dual agent (§ 54.1-2139.1)

“Dual agent” and “dual representative” mean the same arrangement under two kinds of contract: an agency relationship for the first, an independent contractor relationship for the second (§ 54.1-2130). The consent rules are the same.

With designated agents, each agent represents only their own client and can’t share your confidential information except with their broker (§ 54.1-2139.1(A)). That keeps a dedicated advocate on each side, which is the main difference from one person doing both jobs.

What does a dual agent stop doing for you?

When the agent already represents one of you and takes on the other as a new client, the disclosure form Virginia prescribes spells out the limits. After dual representation starts, the licensee:

  • Can’t advise either party on the terms to offer or accept in an offer or counteroffer
  • Can’t advise the buyer on whether the property suits them or on its condition, beyond disclosures the law requires
  • Can’t advise either party on what repairs to make or request
  • Can’t advise either party in a dispute about the transaction
  • May be acting without knowing your needs, your knowledge of the market or how comfortable you are with the process

The form also tells both clients that either one may hire another licensee, at additional cost, to represent their interests (§ 54.1-2139(H)). And the agent can’t pass along confidential information either of you shared, except what Virginia law requires or permits to be disclosed.

Put simply, a dual agent becomes closer to a facilitator. Negotiating price, deciding what to ask for after the home inspection and working through a disagreement are exactly the moments most buyers and sellers want advice.

  • Before it starts. The written disclosure goes to both parties before dual representation begins (§ 54.1-2139(A)). The Real Estate Board’s rule sets the latest points: the buyer before the offer is presented to the agent who will present it, and the seller before the offer is presented to the seller (18VAC135-20-220).
  • Your signature, on its own document. A disclosure doesn’t count if the client didn’t sign it, or if it’s tucked into the purchase agreement or another transaction document (§ 54.1-2139(D)).
  • Plus a written brokerage agreement. The disclosure doesn’t replace the written agreement every client must have, which has to state the fee and the services (§ 54.1-2137(C)).

What if you say no?

You’re allowed to refuse. The agent may then withdraw from representing the client who refused, without liability, and can keep representing the other client (§ 54.1-2139(G)). If you’re the buyer, that usually means you bring in your own agent. If you’re the seller, your listing agent may step back from that particular buyer’s offer, and the buyer can be represented by someone else.

Before you list, read how your listing agreement handles dual and designated agency, and ask how the firm decides between them.

Should a buyer call the listing agent directly?

You can, and the listing agent has to tell you in writing early on that they represent the seller (§ 54.1-2138). They also owe you honesty and must disclose known material adverse facts about the physical condition of the property (§ 54.1-2131(B)). What they can’t do while representing the seller is advocate for you.

If the listing agent offers to represent you too, ask yourself who will tell you whether the price makes sense, how to write your offer and what to ask for after inspection. If the answer is “no one,” consider your own agent. The same question applies to new construction, where the builder’s sales staff work for the builder.

Questions to ask before you sign a dual or designated agency disclosure

  1. Will one person represent both of us, or will the broker assign separate agents?
  2. What advice will I lose once it starts, and what advice have you already given the other side?
  3. How will the commission be handled, and is it in writing?
  4. Who supervises the transaction, and how is confidential information protected?
  5. What happens if I decline?

When I talk with clients about dual agency, I start with those questions, because the answers tell you whether you’ll still have an advocate when the negotiation gets hard.

What’s the next step?

If you’re buying, Daniel and the Keeton & Co team can represent you as your own agent from first showing to closing. See how we work with buyers. If you’re selling and want to understand how buyer agents and in-house buyers are handled before you list, talk to our team about selling or contact us.

No pressure, no spam

Talk to a Keeton & Co agent

A licensed agent reaches out within 5 minutes during business hours, from (804) 556-1228.

By submitting, you agree that Keeton & Co Real Estate and its agents may call and text you at the number you provided about your real estate inquiry, including by automated means and AI-generated or prerecorded voice. Consent is not a condition of purchase. Msg & data rates may apply. Reply STOP to opt out. Privacy Policy

More on buying